Peanut Butter and Mayo Sandwich Shocks the Internet

Peanut Butter and Mayo Sandwich

This classic Southern staple has the internet debating its deliciousness. . .or lack thereof.

Apparently, the unusual pairing has been making the rounds on social media with people arguing for or (very) against this unusual concoction.

An article in Garden & Gun magazine, which covers the Southern home and food trends, traced the origins of this sandwich to the Great Depression, when it was an affordable option for many … and as popular as peanut butter and jelly in some areas.

Arby’s Brings Back the Venison Sandwich

A Facebook page dedicated to the sandwich combo showcases an ad for Skippy and Hellman’s together, suggesting the pairing:

Credit: facebook.com/pbandmayo

JIF peanut butter even has a recipe for a Peanut Butter BLT Sandwich on its website that calls for peanut butter, lettuce, tomatoes, bacon and mayonnaise or a creamy salad dressing.

Jodie Pottorff Mull, who lives in Blue Ridge, Georgia, but grew up in North and South Carolina, as well as Florida, told TODAY Food via Facebook that she grew up eating peanut butter and mayonnaise sandwiches, often on Saturday for lunch after going grocery shopping. “A special treat was to add bananas as well as the mayo,” she said. “However, I have never met anyone else who didn’t make a face when I mentioned it.”

Chef Nathan Thurston of Millers All Day in Charleston, South Carolina, told TODAY Food he grew up taking peanut butter, banana and mayonnaise sandwiches to school in Greensboro, North Carolina. Thurston said it was a family tradition that he still enjoys eating today — and he’s even considered adding a hot, griddled version to the menu at his restaurant.

Of course, the internet can’t decide if this is a match made in heaven or too yucky to comprehend.